I was reading an article on Ars Technica about a consumer advocacy group in the the Netherlands who suggest that customers should downgrade to XP if they end up with Vista.
I’m convinced that maybe, just maybe, I’ve ended up with a different version of Windows Vista than other people. While I may have just upgraded my computer from Windows XP to Windows Vista within the last month, I have been using it at work since sometime in May, and have few problems. Hell, in some cases I’ve had things work better than they did in Windows XP. One example of this is my secondary monitor I use, which connects to the docking station my Latitude D820 uses throughout the week. I use the extended display option, and the monitor is on the left hand side and the laptop is on the right. Whenever I would undock for the weekend and use the computer at home, when I was next at work, XP was always convinced that the monitor was on the right hand side. While not a big issue, I then had to go into the settings each and every time. I don’t recall having to do that with Vista once, or if I did, it was the first time and the first time only.
Of course, this is just one of the many instances of people voicing issues that Vista isn’t ready. Again, it might just be me, but I have had better performance on both machines with Vista than I had with XP. On my home computer, I run Lord of the Rings Online, and I play in windowed mode so I can still easily get to Firefox, Pidgin, or Thunderbird while I’m playing in case I want to look something up or I’m doing something (riding between cities or crafting) that doesn’t require my attention. XP used to hate when I tried to do this, even with the full 2GB of memory I had in the system when I did a quick test run, whereas Vista has no issue. Since I have a decent video card, when I tab around between windows, via the Alt or Windows key method, it still displays what is going on in LotRO while I’m doing so. Sure, Macintosh OS X had this as one of their big things when they would talk about how awesome it was, so I see no reason not to say it about Windows.
I do agree with the article that Vista’s security model is superior to XP, and unlike the “Mac & PC” commercials (which to me is like saying, if it was for comparing cars, “Prius & American cars”), Vista does not prompt to stop you from doing something all the time. It’s just another step to get users to realize that they are about to do something that will affect their system. Sure, when you are trying to administer a system, those prompts might get annoying, but I like them nonetheless, and consider them good for normal, everyday users, especially since they prevent you from clicking anywhere else on the screen until you make a choice.
Due to the fact that computers are coming with Vista, and the users will need to get used to it, I personally don’t recommend downgrading from Vista to XP. My mom had asked me to do that on a new laptop she had and I simply said no, as the computer would no longer have many of the default programs that were set up for that laptop model, and eventually she would have to use Vista anyway and XP would no longer be supported, which require an upgrade back to Vista. On another note, since I don’t have to administer computers on a network or domain, install software that isn’t Vista compliant, or deal with locking down computers from users, I have no problem using Vista or recommending it to others, provided that the computer it’s going on can handle it. While I’m interested in Ubuntu, I also am interested in LotRO, and don’t want to have to boot back and forth between OS environments, so I’m sticking with Windows for now.
Then again, that’s just me.




Latest Comments